When you’re planning a hiking or backpacking trip, staying dry is just as important as staying fed or warm. But one common question many backpackers ask is:
Should I carry a backpacking poncho or a rain jacket?
The answer depends on several things- like where you’re going, the weather, how light you want to pack, and your comfort level. In this article, we’ll compare ponchos and rain jackets so you can decide what’s best for your next trip.
What is a Backpacking Poncho?
A backpacking poncho is a large, waterproof piece of fabric with a hood and often snaps or ties along the sides. It’s usually big enough to cover both you and your back pack.
Pros of a Poncho:
- Covers your backpack too: No need for a separate rain cover.
- Lightweight and packable: Most ponchos weigh less than a jacket.
- Great for ventilation: Loose fit means more airflow, reducing sweat.
- Multi-use: Some ponchos can double as a shelter or groundsheet.
Cons of a Poncho:
- Flaps in the wind: Can be annoying or noisy in strong winds.
- Less fitted: May feel bulky or awkward on steep trails.
- Not ideal for bushwhacking: Gets caught on branches and rocks.
What Is a Rain Jacket?
A rain jacket is a fitted waterproof layer that zips up the front, usually with sealed seams and a hood. It’s part of most modern hiking and outdoor gear kits.
Pros of a Rain Jacket:
- Tight fit: Better for moving fast or climbing.
- Windproof: Usually better protection in storms.
- More durable: Designed to last through rough terrain.
- Modern tech: Many have breathable fabric (like Gore-Tex).
Cons of a Rain Jacket:
- Can trap heat: Not much airflow unless it has vents.
- Only covers you: You’ll need a separate rain cover for your backpack.
- Heavier and bulkier: Especially models with layers or insulation.
Poncho vs Rain Jacket
| Feature | Poncho | Rain Jacket |
| Weight | Very light (5–10 oz) | Light to moderate (10–20 oz) |
| Coverage | You + backpack | Just your body |
| Ventilation | Excellent | Limited |
| Wind Protection | Poor to moderate | Good |
| Versatility | High (shelter, groundsheet) | Low |
| Price Range | $20–$70 | $50–$200+ |
When to Choose a Backpacking Poncho
A poncho is best if:
- You’re hiking in hot and wet climates (like Southeast Asia or the Amazon).
- You want a lightweight, budget-friendly option.
- You don’t expect strong winds or rough terrain.
- You want something that can be used in multiple ways (e.g., as a tarp or emergency shelter).
When to Choose a Rain Jacket
A rain jacket is ideal if:
- You’re hiking in cold, windy, or alpine environments.
- You care about mobility and durability.
- You want something that performs well in stormy weather.
- You already carry a separate rain cover for your backpack.
What Should You Pack?
So, poncho or rain jacket?
If you’re all about saving weight, staying cool, and using gear in many ways- go for the poncho.
If you prefer durability, storm protection, and a more fitted feel—go for the rain jacket.
Still unsure? Think about your destination, weather, and hiking style. You can even test both on short hikes before committing to one for a long trip.
FAQs: Poncho vs Rain Jacket for Backpacking
Yes! Some hikers wear a rain jacket and keep a poncho in their pack as a backup or to cover their bag during heavy storms.
Ponchos win here. They are usually lighter and more multi-purpose.
Many thru-hikers use ponchos because of the weight savings. But if your trail has cold or stormy sections, a rain jacket might be better.
Most are, but cheap ponchos can leak at the seams. Look for taped seams or use a DIY seam sealer.
